Hurry—our Last Minute Stocking Stuffer Sale is your final chance to get 30% off and free shipping on orders over $35! Order by 12/14 to ensure delivery just in time for Christmas Eve. Don’t miss out on these festive favorites!
Mix a Blood Orange Old Fashioned Like a Professional Bartender
The Old Fashioned is the gold standard of cocktails—a drink that separates casual mixologists from serious bartenders. But here’s the secret professional bartenders won’t tell you: there’s a shortcut that makes this classic even better. With Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Cocktail Syrup, you can craft a sophisticated, restaurant-quality Blood Orange Old Fashioned in your own home without fussing over muddling fruit or spending hours infusing spirits.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through the techniques professionals use to nail this drink every single time.
Why the Blood Orange Old Fashioned Works
The Old Fashioned depends on balance—spirit-forward, lightly sweet, and brightened by citrus. Classic versions use sugar cubes, bitters, and an orange twist, which can take some practice to master.
Blood orange adds a fresh twist. Its tart, floral notes complement bourbon or rye without overpowering it, while the bold color feels seasonal and elevated.
And with Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Syrup, the drink becomes effortless: no guessing on sweetness, no muddling sugar cubes, and no inconsistent results from glass to glass.
The Professional Technique: Blood Orange Old Fashioned
Ingredients
- 2 oz bourbon or rye whiskey (your choice—both work beautifully)
- ½ oz Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Syrup
- 2–3 dashes Angostura bitters
- Large ice cube or hand-cut block
- Orange twist for garnish
- Water (optional, for dilution)
-
Blood Orange Cocktail Syrup
Price range: $15.99 through $28.99 Shop Now This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Equipment You’ll Need
- Rocks glass (also called a lowball glass)
- Mixing glass or bar pitcher
- Barspoon (or a long-handled spoon)
- Channel knife or vegetable peeler (for the twist)
- Jigger (for measuring, if you don’t have one, a shot glass works)
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prep Your Glass and Ice: Chill a rocks glass with ice, then dump before pouring. Use one large ice cube to avoid quick dilution.
- Build Your Base: Add 2 oz bourbon or rye to a mixing glass, then add ½ oz Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Syrup.
- Add the Bitters: Add 2–3 dashes of Angostura bitters for depth and aroma.
- Add a Splash of Water: Add about ¼ oz water to help the flavors blend. Optional but recommended.
- Stir, Don’t Shake: Add a large ice cube and stir for 15 seconds until chilled and properly diluted.
- Strain into Your Glass: Place a large cube in your chilled rocks glass and strain the cocktail over it, using a fine strainer.
- Garnish with Purpose: Express an orange peel over the drink to release citrus oils, then drop it into the glass.
Why Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Syrup Beats Traditional Methods
Speed and Consistency
Muddling sugar cubes takes time and leaves residue at the bottom of your glass. Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Syrup dissolves instantly, giving you consistent flavor every single time. Make one for yourself, then make five more for guests—they’ll all taste exactly right.
No Waste
A fresh blood orange adds juice and pulp that can muddy your drink. With our syrup, you get pure, concentrated flavor without any sediment. Plus, it lasts up to two months refrigerated once opened, so you’re never caught without an ingredient mid-party.
Professional Quality
Our syrup is made with natural ingredients, real cane sugar, and blood orange juice concentrate—the same quality ingredients professionals in high-end bars use. No artificial flavors, no corn syrup, just authentic cocktail craftsmanship in a bottle.
Versatility Beyond the Old Fashioned
That bottle of Blood Orange Syrup isn’t a one-trick pony. Use it in margaritas, martinis, palomas, gin sours, vodka mules, and even sophisticated mocktails. You’re investing in a home bar staple that earns its shelf space.
Variations to Try Once You've Mastered the Classic
Blood Orange Old Fashioned with a Spicy Twist
Add ⅛ oz of habanero hot sauce or a few drops of your favorite hot sauce after the bitters. The heat complements the citrus beautifully and adds complexity. This is perfect for those who like their cocktails with a kick.
Blood Orange & Ginger Old Fashioned
Replace ¼ oz of the Blood Orange Syrup with ¼ oz of Liquid Alchemist Ginger Syrup. The warming spice of ginger combined with the blood orange’s brightness creates a drink that feels almost autumnal—perfect for fall entertaining.
The Grenadine Float
Stir your Blood Orange Old Fashioned as described, then carefully layer a barspoon of Liquid Alchemist Grenadine into the glass by pouring it slowly over the back of the spoon. The grenadine sinks to the bottom, creating a beautiful ruby layer that adds sweetness and visual drama.
Pro Tips from Professional Bartenders
Invest in Quality Ice:
The biggest difference between a home bartender and a professional is ice. If you’re serious about your cocktails, consider an ice tray that makes larger cubes or blocks. It’s worth every penny.
Measure Everything:
Using a jigger (measuring tool) ensures consistency. Even experienced bartenders measure—it’s not a shortcut, it’s a standard.
Chill Your Glassware:
Never pour a cocktail into a warm glass. It’s the fastest way to dilute your drink before you even take the first sip.
Taste as You Go:
If you make multiple drinks, taste the first one. Does it need more bitters? More citrus? Adjust accordingly for the next round.
Fresh Citrus for Garnish:
While our Blood Orange Syrup is shelf-stable and consistent, the twist should be fresh. Peel it just before serving for maximum aroma and oil expression.
Host Like a Professional: Making Blood Orange Old Fashioneds for a Crowd
One of the best-kept secrets of professional bartenders is batch preparation. Here’s how to make eight perfect Blood Orange Old Fashioneds without standing at the bar all night:
The Batch Method:
- Combine 16 oz bourbon or rye with 4 oz Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Syrup and 24 dashes of Angostura bitters in a pitcher
- Prepare eight rocks glasses with large ice cubes
- Pour the batch evenly into each glass
- Garnish each with a fresh orange twist
Your guests will think you’ve been practicing for weeks. You’ll know it only takes five minutes and one bottle of premium syrup.
Ready to Mix Like a Pro?
The Blood Orange Old Fashioned is your entry point to professional-level cocktail making. It’s elegant enough for a dinner party, straightforward enough for a casual Friday night, and impressive enough to make your guests wonder if you attended bartending school.
Shop Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Syrup in 12oz ($15.99) or 25oz ($28.99) sizes. One bottle gives you dozens of perfect cocktails—and that’s before you start experimenting with the variations we’ve shared.
Pro tip: Start with our Best Seller Sample Pack ($25.00) to explore multiple Liquid Alchemist flavors and find your favorites. Or grab the Margarita 3-Pack ($39.99) to master more classic cocktails.
First-time customers get 25% OFF + Free Shipping with code TRYUS on your first order. That’s your chance to stock your home bar with professional-grade syrups at an unbeatable price.
Take Your Cocktail Game Further
Want to master more classic cocktails? Download our free “Master Cocktail Techniques” guide—featuring essential skills like proper stirring, shaking, layering, and garnishing. Grab your free guide here.
Or explore our full collection of Blood Orange Cocktail Syrup recipes and discover new ways to use this versatile syrup beyond the Old Fashioned. From margaritas to martinis, blood orange brings sophistication to every glass.
Mix well, and tell us about your Blood Orange Old Fashioned on Instagram—we love seeing what our community creates.
Compare: Why Liquid Alchemist Stands Apart
Feature | Liquid Alchemist | Mass-Market Syrups | Muddling Fresh Fruit |
Natural Ingredients | ✓ Real cane sugar, natural flavors, no HFCS | ✗ Often artificial or high-fructose corn syrup | ✓ But inconsistent quality |
Consistency | ✓ Same perfect flavor every time | ✓ Consistent, but artificial taste | ✗ Varies by fruit ripeness |
Shelf Life | ✓ 2 years unopened, 2 months refrigerated | ✓ Long shelf life | ✗ Only days when fresh |
Ease of Use | ✓ Dissolves instantly, no prep | ✗ Often requires heating or extra steps | ✗ Time-consuming muddling |
Professional Quality | ✓ Trusted by bartenders since 2009 | ✗ Designed for mass production | ✓ Fresh fruit quality potential |
Price Per Drink | ✓ ~$0.60–$1.00 per drink | ~ Similar range | ~ Higher (fresh fruit cost) |
Professional Results | ✓ Every time | ✗ Often falls short | ~ Requires skill and experience |
Your Next Step
You now have everything you need to make a professional-quality Blood Orange Old Fashioned. The technique is simple, the ingredients are premium, and the results are guaranteed to impress.
Start with one perfect drink tonight. Then make it for others. Before long, you won’t just be mixing cocktails—you’ll be mixing them like a professional.
Shop Blood Orange Cocktail Syrup now and join thousands of home bartenders who’ve elevated their cocktail game with Liquid Alchemist.
FAQs
Can I use the same syrup for other cocktails?
Absolutely. Liquid Alchemist Blood Orange Syrup works beautifully in margaritas, martinis, palomas, gin sours, vodka mules, and sophisticated mocktails. One bottle earns its shelf space many times over.
What’s the difference between bourbon and rye in this drink?
Bourbon brings warmth and vanilla notes that complement blood orange’s tartness. Rye adds spice and complexity. Try both and see which flavor profile you prefer—there’s no wrong choice.
Do I really need a mixing glass and barspoon?
Ideally, yes. They help you achieve proper dilution and temperature control. But if you don’t have them, a pitcher and regular spoon work in a pinch. What matters most is stirring steadily for 15 seconds.
Why use one large ice cube instead of regular ice?
Large ice melts slower, keeping your drink cold without over-diluting it. If you don’t have large cubes, use the biggest ones from your freezer and avoid tiny ice chips.
How long does an opened bottle of Blood Orange Syrup last?
Unopened bottles store for up to two years at room temperature. Once opened, refrigerate for up to two months. Always shake well before using.
Can I make this as a mocktail?
Yes. Skip the whiskey and add ½ oz more sparkling water or ginger beer. You’ll get the same sophisticated flavor without the alcohol—perfect for inclusive entertaining.
Is there a faster way to make multiple drinks?
The batch method (our Cocktails for a Crowd section) is your answer. Combine all ingredients in a pitcher, then pour into prepared glasses. It’s faster and foolproof.
